http://forums.delphiforums.com/sunkopitiam/messages?msg=28274.97
IT WAS a women's meet but the issue of men came to the fore repeatedly.
Barely minutes after the meeting started yesterday, a woman raised an objection.
Singapore Integrated Socio-Political Blogosphere
http://forums.delphiforums.com/sunkopitiam/messages?msg=28274.97
Let's put it this way ..when the press and media are explicitly and government implicitly in support of the Old guards..how can the New Guards win? And Look at Pearl Forss of CNA so happy when she announced the results! From the very minute Josie was reprimanded by her bank the DBS for her role in AWARE, it was clear she was somewhat a pawn, fighting the odds! God in heaven and perhaps also on earth... wasn't willing to give her that miracle to win!
Of course Derek Hong's about turn did not help either . As to why the about turn of a Pastor who has always been strong in his views, your guess is as good as mine.
The only good thing about the whole issue is that parents are now more AWARE that what is recommended by AWARE in the sex education curriculum MAY NOT be the right sort of value teachings, they want for their kids. SECONDLY that if they do not voice their concerns regarding any issue, the government takes it to mean "everything is fine !"
The MOE also cannot support the new Guard simply because to do so would be tantamount to admitting they have not been vigilant enough in their scrutiny of Aware's sex education curriculum for schools.
Dr Thio's appearance as Femininist mentor certainly did not help the cause of the new guards. She is known for her conservative and perhaps more ultra extreme conservative Christian views. The Old Guards boosted with the media reports of warnings from government leaders as well as socially correct viewpoints of various religious leaders of different religions, very cleverly play the religious card-(that this was a secular organisation turning Christian)
Now playing along that line of reasoning, they quickily won over supporters of other religious inclinations. Rightly or wrongly - the "fear factor came into the minds of those of other religious persuasions- "oh we cannot allow this organistion to be "taken over " by Christians. Though logically, no decent Muslim Hindu or Buddhist would have agreed that " anal sex can be healthy ..or homo is neutral or Pink family is ok." as taught in the aware sex education curriculum Thus the strong significance religion still holds- in the political positioning of issues here.
Dr Thio may not realise this , but by terming herself as Feminist Mentor , it could have been viewed as if she was ridiculing the MM . When the MM is termed Mentor ...it makes sense NOT to use the same terminology "mentor". She could have called herself Senior member, Guide, Honorary Adviser ..whatever but she unwittingly chose to call herself a Feminist Mentor!
As I had said earlier I applaud Josie for her daring, in taking on the marauding horde of lesbians and gays, but she probably didn't realise in reality how formidable they can be. HER heart and spirit may have been in the right place for the sake of our kids , but she could be wearing shoes too big for her feet, based upon her poor performance at the EOGM. She seemed to have lost her cool too many times, unfortunately! Nevertheless, she should be commended for at least trying.
For those who have followed the events closely, the whole episode clearly shows how potent the "invisible hand " of the government functions, in influencing success or failure of ANY group seeking office even in organisations- secular and/or religious.
Without the tacit support of the government ( even when they say they do not interfere) and without the "help " of the press in "shaping" public opinion , it is difficult for any group to succeed in their objective! And that is reality for us in Singapore!
http://forums.delphiforums.com/sunkopitiam/messages?msg=27734.314
Former AWARE president Dana Lam takes office as new president
By Cheryl Lim, Channel NewsAsia | Posted: 03 May 2009 0318 hrs
Some 3,000 people turn up for AWARE EGM | ||||||
SINGAPORE : Ms Dana Lam is the new president of AWARE (Association for Woman's Action and Research).
This development took place almost seven hours after the extraordinary meeting began at Suntec City.
Requests were made for Ms Josie Lau and her team to step down from office.
While her legal counsel said Ms Lau and her team were not legally obliged to do so, a short break was called for them to decide if they would step down.
Ms Lau's legal counsel said that in while the exco had been elected into office for a finite period of time, office bearers in similar situations would usually step down out of courtesy, custom and common sense would.
But when the team headed by Ms Lau along with then honorary secretary Ms Jenica Chua, failed to return after 20 minutes, members decided they could not wait any longer, and declared that the exco led by Lau has resigned.
A vote was also taken on the motion to remove Ms Lau's team from office.
Order of business then moved to the voting in of office bearers for the new executive committee - former AWARE president Danna Lam was voted in as president, with former honorary treasurer Chew I-Jin voted into office, this time as vice-president.
Other members on the team included familiar faces of former exco members, Corinna Lim and Margaret Thomas, with new faces making up almost half the team.
The full list of the newly-elected exco is as follows -
Dana Lam, President
Chew I-Jin, Vice President
Yap Ching Wi, Honorary Secretary
Corinna Lim, Assisitant Honorary Secretary
Tan Joo Hymn, Honorary Treasurer
Lim Seow Yuin, Assistant Honorary Treasurer
Committee Members - Margaret Thomas, Hafizah Osman, Nancy Griffiths, Nicole Tan, Joanna D' Cruz, Martha Lee
But before the full list of office bearers was voted in, Ms Lau and her team made a surprise return, and announced they would be resigning.
At a separate news conference, Miss Lau said she was not surprised by the results.
But does the outcome spell the end to collaborations with AWARE?
"If the new team should invite me back to advise on education and training, I'd be more than willing to do that," said Charlotte Wong, former AWARE vice-president.
Speaking to the media, the new AWARE President Ms Lam said her first task would be to arrange for transition of office.
"(We'll) take back control of our centre, and see whether we can restore some of the confidence that has been lost over the last few weeks. Don't forget that we have had quite a number of people who have resigned. And some people are new, and have been employed by the new executive committee. So, I think there is really quite a lot of things we will have to do," said Lam.
Singapore Council of Women's Organisations (SCWO) said it is pleased to note that AWARE has reached a resolution in a democratic manner.
In a statement, President of SCWO, Dr Ann Tan said SCWO would like to underscore once again the need for civil societies to function as and remain as secular organisations so that all will stand to benefit from their good works. And that it trusts that AWARE will fulfil the mandate that they have been given to carry on with their work.
SCWO looks forward to working with AWARE to achieve common goals for the well being of the women of Singapore. - CNA /ls
http://forums.delphiforums.com/sunkopitiam/messages?msg=28274.96
Aware Saga 7 MAR 1986: | |||||
The day we all became Aware | |||||
Founders of women's group shared concern for women issues in society | |||||
| |||||
| |||||
BACK in the eighties, a new women's group held its forums at Queenstown library, just across the road from the church where six of today's new exco members worship.
Back then, the Association of Women for Action and Research (Aware) was driven by ideals. Now it is largely seen as farcical, with furious in-fighting, disputes and politicking. Mention Aware today and one is likely to think of a catfight among two groups of women. Other images: Christians taking on pro-gay groups, lockouts with police called in, dramatic press conferences. Where is the dignity? Where is the sense of mission or unity? It was hard work, said founding member Zaibun Siraj recalling the beginning, but 'we had such fun'. That was back in 1984, when the organisation was founded 'quite by accident', said the first Aware president, Mrs Lena Lim U Wen, 71. She set up Select Books in 1976, and was its first managing director until 2004 when she retired. The idea for Aware arose from a forum called 'Women's Choices, Women's Lives' at the National University of Singapore Society, in November 1984, attended by about 50 women.
Aware's founding members - among them Mrs Hedwig Anuar, Dr Lai Ah Eng, MsZaibun Siraj, Dr Vivienne Wee, Ms Chua Siew Keng, Ms Evelyn Wong, and Mrs Lim - were unhappy about several issues discussed in the 1983 National Day Rally. They were against the population policies then, such as one which gave graduate mothers priority in getting their children registered in their preferred school. As the women were dispersing, Ms Wong called out rhetorically: 'What are we going to do now?' About 15 women decided to meet exactly one month later to talk about the way forward. Some, like Mrs Lim, knew about women whose husbands had deserted them, and of women who had been battered for years, but who were too afraid to speak up for fear of airing dirty linen in public. Said Mrs Lim: 'In those days, they would hide their bruises because they couldn't bear the shame of letting people know they were beaten.' She also knew women who led bitter, disgruntled lives as second and third wives. She swore to work for them and never to allow herself to be in such a situation. Said Dr Lai, 54, a social scientist: 'We had the same feeling about wanting to do something for women in general. For me, these concerns also affect the family, the community and society at large.' These women could not find an existing women's organisation that shared similar views, so they decided to start a new organisation.
And that eventually grew to become Aware. Said Mrs Lim: 'When we started out, we were unpopular with men, women and the authorities. 'Back then, when we forwarded victims of domestic violence to the police, we were seen as meddling in police matters.' 'Women's Freedom' Mrs Anuar, 80, the first woman to be appointed director of the National Library in 1965, came up with the name. She joked that Aware could have been called 'Singapore Women', 'Women's Liberty' or 'Women's Freedom'. A friend of Mrs Lim came up with the Aware logo, consisting of the name and the symbol for female. For a year, they operated as a pro-tem committee, writing and refining their constitution until it was approved by the Singapore Registrar of Societies. On 9 Dec 1985, the founding members had their first official meeting. And on 7 March 1986, Aware was formally launched at the Cairnhill Community Centre. For four years, the members met in their kitchens, waiting rooms and offices, mostly in the evenings after work. The 'host' would normally prepare some food for the rest. They paid for stationery and food from their own pockets. There were no computers, so sub-committee heads had to use typewriters to churn out circulars and documents. Aware's first forums and seminars were held at community centres and libraries, particularly the Queenstown library. It was only in 1990 that the first Aware Centre was established out, in a second storey shophouse on Race Course Road. It was made available for use through Ms Claire Chiang, also an Aware member. Mrs Lim said: 'One room was for the helpline, one for files, and the corridor was for meetings.' Mrs Anuar recalled: 'On the first storey was an Indian restaurant, and we often ended up having Indian food for lunch, because it was right in front of us.' She added that money then was a problem, and all the furniture was donated and second-hand. There were very few chairs and, during meetings, some members sat on straw mats. Mrs Lim said: 'It was okay, we didn't mind.' She added: 'I grew in Aware. I have a fear of public speaking, which I had to face up to whenever I had to make speeches as president. I learnt a lot.' Through it all, the issues were what drove the founding leaders. Ms Zaibun said: 'There were just a few of us in that original committee, but we took on every single issue related to women - from women in the civil service, media, education. 'That's what Aware is for - to represent all women, and to address all issues. And in the process, we had such fun.'
I regret actions: Pastor Hong FURTHER to Bishop John Chew's and my statement of 1 May 2009 in the media, I agree with him that the pulpit should not have been used in this Aware saga. I regret that this matter has caused concern and unhappiness. My actions on the pulpit have aroused some tension in this saga. I now stand corrected. I undertake to be more sensitive to similar situations in the future.
Tolerance and restraint needed: DPM Wong 'I welcome the statement by Dr John Chew, President of the National Council of Churches of Singapore. 'In our compact multi-ethnic and multi-religious society, racial and religious harmony underpins our stability. One of the key rules of engagement, therefore, is the need for tolerance and restraint by all groups. This is the only practical way, for all groups, regardless of their size or material influence, to enjoy maximum space to pursue their different faiths in peace. 'I thank the NCCS for its statement which soberly reminds us of this reality. It makes clear the Council's responsible stand. It will help prevent any misunderstanding that the churches are backing one side in the Aware dispute, or that this is a dispute between Christians and other Singaporeans.' - Deputy Prime Minister Wong Kan Seng
PAST, PRESENT, FUTURE? 7 MAR 1986: These milestone changes in gender issues were effected in part due to Aware's work in advocacy and research. 1989: Advertising Standards Authority of Singapore develops new guidelines to curb gender discrimination in advertisements 1994: MOE stops requiring girls to take home economics and boys to take technical studies, offers 'Life Skill for Boys and Girls' instead. 1996: Women's Charter revised to provide more protection for victims of domestic violence. 1999: Women allowed to sponsor foreign spouses for citizenship and permanent resident status. 2003: NUS lifts quota restricting the intake of female students into its medical faculty. 2004: Government acknowledges men and women play equal roles as joint heads of household. 2005 Same citizenship rights are accorded to the children of Singaporean women, as those of Singaporean men. 28 Mar 2009: At AGM, nine of 12 available exco positions go to new members, most of whom had joined Aware only in the last six months. 8 Apr 2009: President Claire Nazar resigns. 14 Apr 2009: 160 old guard members call EGM for vote of no confidence in new exco. 15 Apr 2009 DBS bank executive Josie Lau elected president, although her employer expressed reservations about her taking the post.
18 Apr 2009 Adviser to the exco Constance Singam resigns. 23 Apr 2009 New guard holds press conference, accuses old guard of promoting homosexuality. Centre manager Schutz Lee fired for alleged 'acts of insubordination'. 30 Apr 2009: Umbrella Christian body (National Council of Churches of Singapore) says churches should stay out of the fray. Today: EGM from 2pm at Suntec City Exhibition Hall 402. Registration begins at noon.
WHAT MIGHT HAPPEN TODAY 1 Vote of no confidence fails. New guard stays. New exco introduces new programmes, including mentoring for younger women by successful role models. It might also announce changes to Aware's schools sexuality programme. 2 Vote of no confidence succeeds. New exco comprises mixture of old and new guard members. As each exco member is chosen by popular vote, each post in new exco will be up for grabs. Old and new guard members might face challenge of mending broken bridges. 3 Vote of no confidence succeeds. New exco comprises entirely of old guard members. Aware returns to the way it was before the saga - all-inclusive. It might have to work on repairing reputation in the eyes of the pubic. 4 Vote of no confidence not mooted. The new guard manages to address and satisfy old guard's concerns, and both sides reach a compromise. The new exco stays, and works together with the old guard in matters of Aware's agenda and programmes. |
http://forums.delphiforums.com/sunkopitiam/messages?msg=28274.89
By Sumiko Tan, Sunday Times Editor | ||
| Ms Josie Lau sharing an intimate moment with her husband, DrAlan Chin, after she and her executive committee stepped down late last night. -- ST PHOTO: CAROLINE CHIA |
On Saturday night DBS Bank vice-president Josie Lau and the six remaining members of her five-week-old executive committee bowed out after losing a vote of no confidence at the Aware extraordinary general meeting.
They handed back the leadership of Aware to the veterans who founded and ran the women's advocacy group for 25 years before the newcomers seized the reins in March. I met Ms Lau at the Four Seasons lounge last Wednesday, before Saturday's dramatic turn of events.
http://forums.delphiforums.com/sunkopitiam/messages?msg=28274.87
By Sandra Davie, Senior Writer | ||
| | Dr Thio Su Mien addressing the crowd at Suntec on Saturday. Amid loud boos and jeering, she held up a 2007 book Aware had published on the women's movement here and said she felt 'very charmed' to have been mentioned in it. -- ST PHOTO: CAROLINE CHIA |
She had called herself that when she revealed on April 23 her key role in bringing about Aware's sudden leadership change.
Men play active role in meeting IT WAS a women's meet but the issue of men came to the fore repeatedly. Barely minutes after the meeting started yesterday, a woman raised an objection. |
Dr Thio, Ms Josie Lau and five others on the executive committee booted out on Saturday all attend the Anglican Church of Our Saviour in Margaret Drive.
On Saturday, amid loud boos and objections, she held up a 2007 book that Aware had published on the women's movement here and pointed out that she was mentioned as the first woman dean of the Law Faculty - from 1969 to 1971 - at the then-University of Singapore. Holding up the book, she said she felt 'very charmed' to have been included.
As the booing and jeering continued, Dr Thio told the crowd: 'Show some respect to your elders.' Someone in the audience responded: 'You have to earn respect.'
Dr Thio had sent out e-mail messages encouraging women to join Aware and change it, but she maintained on Saturday it was no 'covert operation'.
Old guard leaders had said that most of the people who came to the March 28 annual general meeting were unknown new faces, and they voted solidly for unknown new faces who took over without saying who they were, or why they were in Aware.
But Dr Thio on Saturday accused long-time members of having fallen asleep. 'You were not interested in your organisation...So don't blame others...don't blame other people. You are not interested. You are not interested!'
She wanted to continue, but she was drowned out by chants of 'Your three minutes are up, three minutes, three minutes.'
Later, she told The Sunday Times she was surprised by the 'anger' and 'vehemence' she felt from the Aware members. 'It's very scary,' she said. 'What is happening to women in Singapore?'
Barely minutes after the meeting started yesterday, a woman raised an objection.
She asked: Why was Nominated MP Siew Kum Hong, a man, allowed to be seated on the right side of the hall, a section reserved for women who were eligible to vote.
Like ordinary members, men can pay $40 annually to join the Association of Women for Action and Research (Aware) as associate members, but they have no voting rights and cannot be elected to the executive committee.
Even so, about 300 or so men - many of whom signed up on the spot - attended yesterday's meeting. They sat on the left side of the hall together with foreign women, who were also not allowed to vote.
While the crowd rumbled with cheers and jeers, Mr Siew remained in his seat in the fifth row, unflinching. A member from the old guard clarified that Mr Siew, who joined Aware last October, served as its legal adviser and should be allowed to remain. The grumbles then died down and the meeting started.
Although the atmosphere among the men in the crowd was calm at first, it grew more lively as the afternoon passed. Several chuckled when the Aware exco members exchanged sharp remarks with female members on the floor.
'She was a man in her previous life. Short and sharp,' joked one man loudly when Ms Josie Lau addressed the audience, causing several men around him to snigger.
There were generally two types of men: Young, articulate men in their 20s or 30s who went to see the issues of civil society being discussed, and men in their 40s to 50s who were mostly fathers and went with their wives.
About two-thirds of the men seemed to be supporters of the old guard. They cheered and pumped their fists when anyone made rebuttals to the points laid out by the team led by Ms Lau. Some heckled and booed as passionately as the women.
'You should get out,' yelled one man to Ms Lau's team.
At one point, the men broke into sonorous chants of 'Where were you?' when former Aware president Constance Singam asked Ms Lau's team where it had been in the group's two decades of existence.
Several men also volunteered as ushers, helping with registration and the distribution of free bottles of water, sandwiches and flowers.
Some men arrived after 3pm and were not allowed to register and denied entry. They kept vigil outside the hall.
'It's very frustrating to hear loud cheers and noise inside and be able to only peep through the door cracks,' said fresh graduate Ed Chan, 30, who stood by the entrance for more than seven hours.
Those who supported the veteran Aware members generally wore white T-shirts with the words 'We are Aware' printed in red.
Those who supported MsLau's committee wore red shirts with the word 'Aware' printed in black.
Analyst C.F. Lam, 47, who was wearing a red shirt, said he was attending the meet 'to defend family values'.
Referring to Aware's Comprehensive Sexuality Education (CSE) programme, which Ms Lau's team had criticised for promoting homosexuality, he said: 'I pay taxes and I want to know what my children are being taught in school. If they are being taught the wrong things, we should speak up.'
Another father, Mr Farid Hamid, 45, took a different stance.
Addressing the crowd during the question-and-answer session held while the votes were being counted, he identified himself as a Muslim father of three girls.
He said he would be 'proud' for his teenage daughters to go through the CSE programme as 'they need to make informed choices, not submit to dogma'.
The issue of male membership was also brought up for scrutiny.
On the accusation that the inclusion of male members has become a mask for male homosexual activists to forward their cause, former chairman of Aware's male chapter, Mr Tan Wah Kiat, 37, said: 'The only masks I wear are SKIIs (facial masks) and I share those with my wife.'
In response, Ms Lau turned to the exco's appointed legal counsel from Rajah & Tann and asked if the Aware Constitution provided for a men's chapter.
When the lawyer said it did not, former Aware president Braema Mathi replied that 'there are feminist men today' and that 'they should be equal partners in the feminist movement'.
But not all the talk was serious.
Several men who took the microphone also elicited much laughter and jeers.
One joked that he was inspired by the meeting to 'write a book and call it Women Are From Mars And Men Are From Venus'.
Trainer Marshall Lee, 47, said of the heated atmosphere: 'One woman I was sitting next to hissed at me as though she was Catwoman. I feel so harassed. Don't harass me. I am only a man.'
-- DEBBIE YONG
http://forums.delphiforums.com/sunkopitiam/messages?msg=28274.86
Exco of women's group steps down after raucous seven-hour meeting and control goes back to the veterans
By Wong Kim Hoh, Senior Writer | ||
| | Outgoing exco members (from left) Charlotte Wong, Maureen Ong, Sally Ang, president Josie Lau and Lois Ng return on stage to announce their resignation. 'We have decided to graciously step down. We wish Aware all the best,' said Ms Lau. While her team was in a room deliberating its options, the members decided to hold their own elections and voted in a new slate of office bearers. -- ST PHOTO: CAROLINE CHIA |
Nearly 3,000 people attended an extraordinary general meeting and over nearly seven action-packed hours, blasted away at the team of unknowns which snatched the Aware leadership on March 28. Then they voted resoundingly to oust the team led by DBS Bank vice-president Josie Lau and inspired by senior lawyer Thio Su Mien. The final tally that they should go: 1,414 to 761.
Live Blog Outnumbered, and out-talked THEY started the meeting brisk and business-like, but just minutes into the extraordinary general meeting (EGM), it was clear that Ms Josie Lau's team was no match for the old guard and its supporters, who outnumbered and outspoke them. First, executive committee (exco) member Lois Ng, who was the master of ceremony, tried to assert herself by requesting Nominated MP Siew Kum Hong, who was seated among the women, to join the men on the other side of the auditorium. Booted out, but Josie Lau's team will stay on In fact, they would even be willing to serve as volunteers if the newly elected executive committee would have them, they said. |
Even then, Ms Lau and her team did not step down immediately. They consulted their lawyer, ignored calls to resign, then were told they could retire for five minutes to decide.
When they did not return, the meeting elected a new executive committee headed by former president Dana Lam. It was half an hour before Ms Lau and her exco reappeared to say that they had decided to step down.
Saturday's meeting at Suntec City Hall 402 drew Aware founders, past presidents and long-time members, as well as many women who joined only in recent weeks.
Many said they had been moved by the tumultuous events since March 28, when a team of new members seized nine of the 12 positions on the exco.
New president Claire Nazar quit 11 days later, to be succeeded by Ms Lau. It then emerged that several of the new leaders attended the Anglican Church of Our Saviour, and were strongly against homosexuality.
Then, Dr Thio revealed that she had encouraged the women to join and change Aware because she felt it was promoting lesbianism and homosexuality. In particular, she attacked an Aware sexuality programme for schools, saying it too promoted homosexuality. She called herself a 'feminist mentor'.
Over the past five weeks, the Aware exco shrank from 12 to eight as members resigned. There were only seven present yesterday, as the eighth, Ms Peggy Leong, did not attend.
Saturday's marathon meeting, which started at 2.30pm, was dominated by Aware stalwarts and their supporters, who criticised the newcomers and Dr Thio for the way they took over the association, disregarded older members and sacked staff. They also criticised the team's lack of diversity.
Ms Lau's team had several hundred supporters at the meeting, but mostly the sparring was done between the audience and the exco, and Dr Thio. There were some tense moments at the start of the meeting, when Nominated Member of Parliament Siew Kum Hong was told to sit with the men and expatriates in one side of the hall. He refused, saying that he was there as a legal adviser for the old guard.
http://forums.delphiforums.com/sunkopitiam/messages?msg=28274.85