Showing posts with label Chew I-Jin. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Chew I-Jin. Show all posts

Saturday, April 25, 2009

Aware: Emotions overflow as women exchange barbs

SHOWDOWN CRACKDOWN LOCKDOWN
Emotions overflow as women exchange barbs
It was a press conference that had everything. Aware called it. The media attended it. And while accusations and clarifications were traded amid tears and raised voices, a lone figure sat, watching.
By Ng Tze Yong
April 25, 2009 Print Ready Email Article

IT was a most extraordinary press conference for a civic organisation, one that was hardly civil, one that began with a near-catfight and ended with an awkward silence.
Click to see larger image
OUTBURST: Right before the press conference could get started, Ms Chew I-Jin, assistant honorary treasurer and member of the old guard, stood up and scolded the new exco. TNP PICTURES: MOHD ISHAK

In the middle: Shouting matches, microphone-snatching, wrist-slapping and reporters interrupting one anothers' questions.

There were accusations that bordered on religious slurs, clarifications, contradictions and utter confusion.

And through it all, a mysterious elderly woman sat at one end of the panel. She introduced herself as 'Feminist Mentor' - a picture of calm alongside exco members who spoke with red eyes and quivering voices.

But before the storm, the calm.

The invitation for the press conference came late in the afternoon. The press was informed sternly: No free admission. Submit the names of your reporters first.

It was a long overdue press conference of the new Exco of Aware. The team had been criticised for remaining largely silent on their agenda ever since they were said to have seized Aware in a planned coup on 28 Mar.

So the reporters arrived at Raffles Town Club well before the 7pm appointment. But the exco members arrived 20 minutes late.

Click to see larger image
NEW EXCO: (from top) Aware President Josie Lau, honorary treasurer Maureen Ong and honorary secretary Jenica Chua.

The chaos started almost immediately.

The five Aware exco members had barely settled into their seats when the first salvo was fired.

Ms Chew I-Jin, the assistant honorary treasurer and a member of the old guard, stood up and started berating the new exco, accusing them of not inviting the old guard.

The new exco sat tight as they tried to defuse the situation.

Sit down, they pleaded. The press conference was only arranged at the last minute, they explained. Ask the press... they can prove it.

It didn't work. The shouting match continued, with Ms Chew waving a bag which contained a presentation she said she wanted to give alongside the new exco's presentation.

Click to see larger image

The new exco continued to plead: If you really care about Aware, sit down and let us explain ourselves.

Ms Chew calmed down finally and took a seat on the third row, behind the media.

Exco member Lois Ng took a deep breath, gathered herself and officially began the press conference amid forced smiles.

The microphone was passed to the new president of Aware, Ms Josie Lau.

Click to see larger image

And all niceties ended. She looked like she was about to explode as she announced that members of the new exco have received death threats.

'What is Singapore coming to? Is this what we have become?' she shouted.

Other members of the new exco took their turns, describing the harrowing days since they were elected, their voices thick with emotion.

They claimed they had been locked out of their email accounts and slandered.

'All this could have been sorted out peacefully between the old and the new guard, but it didn't happen,' said Ms Lau.

All this while, the elderly woman sat at one end of the table, a picture of calm and serenity.

This 'Feminist Mentor' introduced herself as Dr Thio Su Mien, a former law dean.

Insiders recognised her as the mother of Nominated Member of Parliament, Dr Thio Li-ann, who became a controversial figure in the gay and lesbian community after speaking out strongly against homosexuality in Parliament last year.

She is also the auntie of Dr Alan Chin, Ms Lau's husband.

'All we want to do is to start working, but we have been unable to,' said Ms Lau.

And with that, the exco members moved on to explain how they planned to lead Aware.

Aware, they said, had previously been hijacked to further the gay agenda.

They pointed out that to celebrate Mother's Day in 2006, Aware invited lesbian-friendly mothers and their lesbian daughters to share their experiences.

In the Aware newsletter, former president Constance Singam also wrote about her outreach to SG Butterflies, a support group for transsexuals.

Aware also supported the screening of Spider Lilies, a movie involving a lesbian couple.

'My plea is that we should re-focus on the excellent objectives of Aware... go back to the original purpose,' said Dr Thio.

The floor was then open questions from reporters.

Do you have more evidence of Aware's gay agenda, one asked. After all, Spider Lilies is just one of many movies Aware has sponsored in the past.

To this, the new exco revealed that the old exco has proposed giving voting rights to men, foreign women and teenagers.

Sudden outburst

'We thought that was a bit odd. Why the sudden shift to give them the vote?' asked Dr Thio.

Back at the third row, Ms Chew buried her head in her hands, then burst out: 'Because we are inclusive!'

'Don't throw words at me!' countered Dr Thio. 'We are a woman's organisation... why don't you form your own group to chase this cause?

'What we want are more Lim Hwee Huas and Chan Heng Chees... women who can inspire us.'

Throughout the question-and-answer session, the new exco members tussled for the lone microphone.

Once, as Ms Ng was in the middle of making a point, Ms Lau, sitting two seats away, reached out her hand for the microphone.

Honorary secretary Jenica Chua, seated between the two of them, lightly tapped her president's wrists, and hushed her.

All this while, a dinner for a golf tournament at the next ballroom was in full swing, with tipsy golfers next door having a lusty go at the karaoke, their songs almost drowning out the exco members' voices at times.

Later, Ms Lau was shot a question about her employer DBS, which had publicly criticised her for taking up the presidency. She declined to answer, explaining she did not have permission to do so.

Honorary Treasurer Maureen Ong and Ms Chua leapt to her defence but, as they spoke, Ms Lau listened and shook her head several times.

Soon, another reporter's hand would shoot up and another hand would reach out to grab the microphone.

Up front, the exco members interrupted one another's long-winded explanations, clarifying one another's points, sometimes resulting in even more confusion.

At one point, Ms Ong mumbled something about changing Syariah law, but when asked to clarify by a reporter, she took it back and said:

'What I want to say is that we are working for all women, whether you are Muslim, Buddhist, Christian...'

'You haven't answered any of our questions!' exclaimed one exasperated reporter.

Said Ms Ng: 'We organised this press conference because we wanted to explain our position.

'Now, we have a question for the media.'

What is the newspapers' role in all of this, she asked. Why the unusually keen interest in the gay agenda?

Her question was met with silence.

And with that, the press conference ended.


3 questions on everyone's lips

  • WHY THE TAKEOVER?

    'If the old guard was that interested in Aware, why did not they turn up for the AGM?'

    Honorary Treasurer Mauren Ong

  • WHAT'S WRONG WITH THE OLD AWARE?

    'Aware seems to be only interested in lesbianism and homosexuality, which is a man's problem.'

    Advisor to new exco, Dr Thio Su Mien

  • DO MEMBERS ATTEND THE SAME CHURCH?

    'Yes, we attend the same church. But not all of us knew one another before joining Aware.'

    Ms Maureen Ong

  • http://forums.delphiforums.com/sunkopitiam/messages?msg=27870.1

    Friday, April 24, 2009

    Aware: Long-time member and new exco lock horns

    Long-time member and new exco lock horns
    IT WAS 7.20pm and 20 minutes past the scheduled start of Thursday's press conference.

    Assistant honorary treasurer Chew I-Jin, part of the old guard, in an exchange with exco members at the press conference. -- ST PHOTO: ALPHONSUS CHERN

    The smartly attired new office bearers of the Association of Women for Action and Research (Aware) were just starting proceedings when a jeans-clad woman carrying a backpack burst into the room.

    'Why do I know nothing about this press conference?...I am utterly disappointed and disgusted,' shouted Ms Chew I-Jin, 40, assistant honorary treasurer of the new committee.

    Ms Chew is one of only two long-time Aware members in the new exco.

    What followed was a brief war of words between her and Ms Lois Ng, 44, a new exco member and one of the panellists.

    Ms Chew was upset that she had been left in the dark about the press conference at the Raffles Town Club, called by Aware president Josie Lau to talk about their difficulties with the old guard.

    Instead, she had been told to attend an exco meeting at the Aware headquarters. She appeared at the press conference after someone alerted her to it.

    She protested that she had been left out despite being a member of the new Aware committee.

    Ms Ng told her the meeting had been called to address 'all the questions the media has about the new faces'.

    She added: 'As you're an old guard member, and the old guard have had their field day giving the media stories upon stories which are totally and utterly inaccurate, this is our chance to talk to the media. 'So I would appreciate that you leave this room.'

    Ms Chew stood her ground, saying that she was all for the new team explaining themselves to the media, and refused to leave. -- Radha Basu


    http://forums.delphiforums.com/sunkopitiam/messages?msg=27734.9

    New exco wants to bring AWARE back to its "original cause"

    New exco wants to bring AWARE back to its "original cause"
    By Cheryl Lim, Channel NewsAsia | Posted: 24 April 2009 0150 hrs



    Photos 1 of 1
    > " onclick="Next();" src="http://www.channelnewsasia.com/images/butt_next.gif" type="image" width="18" height="15">

    AWARE hosts press conference



    Related News

    Showdown at AWARE office over lock change by new exco

    AWARE old guard says debate is healthy

    AWARE president says will not step down despite pressure

    AWARE president gives first media interview since appointment
    Video
    New exco wants to bring AWARE back to its 'original cause'
    Showdown at AWARE office over lock change by new exco

    SINGAPORE : Bringing Aware back to its "original cause" - that is what the new executive committee (exco) of advocacy group, the Association of Women for Action and Research (AWARE), is planning to do.

    In an emotionally-charged news conference on Thursday, the new guard said AWARE has lost its focus.

    They accused the old guard of steering AWARE into becoming a single purpose organisation.

    Drama erupted even before the news conference started with current Honorary Treasurer Chew I-Jin accusing the new guard of intentionally excluding her from their news conference.

    "I'm utterly disappointed and disgusted because I'm meant to do a presentation alongside you, Lois (Ng, Executive Committee member)," said Chew.

    During the one-and-a-half hour event, the group introduced well-known corporate lawyer Dr Thio Su Mien, as their so-called "feminist mentor".

    Dr Thio is the Senior Executive Director of TSMP Law Corporation and mother of Nominated MP, Dr Thio Li Ann.

    The new exco said AWARE had become a single purpose organisation overly concerned with promoting lesbianism.

    They repeatedly raised examples, like how the old guard had backed a lesbian film screening in 2007 and organised a lesbian-friendly Mother's Day event in 2006. And they wanted to bring the association back to what they say is its original noble cause.

    When contacted for comment, former AWARE president Margaret Thomas said those comments were ridiculous and not deserving of any comment.

    Dr Thio Su Mien also revealed that she had emailed several groups with her concerns about the direction the association was taking, which prompted reporters to ask if the takeover was orchestrated.

    "It depends on what you mean by organising. It is kind of flattering in a way. I'm frustrated, I talk to people, I collect info, I send to different people. You want to join, (then) join. I will help you. We discover that networking helps," said Dr Thio, adviser to the new AWARE exco.

    The new exco said none of them intend to step down, but revealed that taking up office has come with risks.

    Several members received death threats which have been reported to the police.

    "Each day, I fear for the physical safety of my children, my family. There's even a blog site detailing my children's names and which schools they go to," said Josie Lau, AWARE's president.

    The team will go ahead with the extraordinary general meeting planned for May 2 and is looking for a new venue to accommodate its burgeoning membership. It is now 880 and still growing. - CNA /ls


    http://forums.delphiforums.com/sunkopitiam/messages?msg=27732.5

    Sunday, April 19, 2009

    'What did she do to deserve position?'

    'What did she do to deserve position?'
    Taken by surprise, Aware veterans question merits of new members standing for recent election
    This is what happened during the Aware AGM, as told to The New Paper by four members who attended the meeting
    By Benson Ang
    April 19, 2009 Print Ready Email Article

    IT ALL began when a hand was raised, innocently enough, by a new member.
    Click to see larger image
    BEATEN: Ms Chew (above), nominated by Ms Singam, was beaten by Ms Wong (below), who was nominated by a new member, by a huge margin for the vice-president's seat. --TNP PICTURES: MOHD ISHAK

    Ms Jenica Chua wanted to nominate Ms Charlotte Wong for vice-president.

    And so began the takeover.

    That 28 Mar annual general meeting (AGM) was to spark a bitter feud between new office-bearers and the old guard of the Association of Women For Action Research (Aware), one that has split the 24-year-old association.

    What exactly happened that day? Four different sources present at the meeting have revealed the twists and turns that led to what amounted to the carpet being pulled from under the Aware stalwarts' feet.

    Ms Wong's nomination raised eyebrows among veterans. A newcomer for vice-president? It was unheard of.

    When Ms Wong made her pitch and listed her credentials, she hardly mentioned a word about feminism.

    Said a source yesterday: 'Many of us wondered what has this woman done for Aware to deserve to be second-in-charge?'

    How do her accomplishments compare to an incumbent, Ms Chew I-Jin, who has been volunteering for more than a decade. How does she compare to someone who has pounded the streets handing out flyers, and manned the phone for hours counselling desperate women?

    How much did Ms Wong even know about Aware? Did she stand a chance?

    She did.

    In hindsight, the first indication that this election would be a watershed was the large turnout.

    By 2pm, the Aware Centre was teaming with women. In previous years, only about 40 people would show up. But this year, there were over 100 - 80 of whom were fresh faces.

    Almost all of them were middle-aged Chinese women. They appeared unfamiliar with the Aware Centre.

    Click to see larger image

    Both the air-conditioned conference room and the lobby had to be used to accommodate the large turnout.

    Shock for veterans

    Ms Constance Singam, 72, the outgoing president and chair of the AGM, nominated Mrs Claire Nazar for presidency. She spoke glowingly about Mrs Nazar's work on the sexual harassment committee.

    Mrs Nazar was elected unopposed.

    Next was the vice-president's seat. Ms Singam nominated Ms Chew, who gave a speech about her involvement with feminism.

    After 15 years in Aware, this was her time to shine.

    Then Ms Wong was nominated.

    When both of them left the room, and it was time to vote, Ms Wong won by a huge margin.

    The veterans were shocked.

    They did not know Ms Wong. Neither did they know the women who voted for her. That was how Aware's No 2 spot went to an unknown.

    This process - whereby a new member would nominate another new member, who was then voted in by new members - repeated itself when Ms Jenica Chua was elected honorary secretary.

    By this time, older members were becoming alarmed. One said she felt uncomfortable with the new members running for positions because they did not understand Aware enough, and had not done enough for Aware.

    But a new member replied that Ms Singam was looking for new faces, and they were new faces.

    The pattern continued. All but one of the key positions were won by large margins - through new voters. Only another key position - assistant honorary treasurer - went to Ms Chew, and it was a walkover.

    When it came to voting in committee members, each of the 13 nominees gave a speech, and the ones with the top six votes were to get in.

    During the meeting, some veteran members started searching the Internet for background on the more vocal new members. They discovered that many of them had written strongly-worded letters to the press against gay lifestyles.

    This, combined with the increasingly obvious voting pattern, prompted the veteran members to start asking a lot more questions.

    A veteran member pointedly asked a new member what she felt about homosexuality. Her reply: She didn't accept it.

    The veteran member rebutted: 'But in Aware, we do not discriminate.'

    The new member said she just did not agree with gay lifestyles. Eventually, she got voted in.

    One nominee, a veteran member, spoke passionately about the need to educate teenagers about safe sex and the dangers of sexually-transmitted diseases.

    She got one of the lowest number of votes.

    Throughout the meeting, several veterans said they were happy that so many people were interested in Aware, but advised these members to familiarise themselves with Aware before running for key positions.

    Their advice went unheeded.

    When the meeting ended at 5.30pm, only three of the 12 were veterans.

    And that was how 28 Mar became the day the old guard of Aware was caught unawares.


    Questions, questions and more contention

    Hidden agenda?

    Ms Josie Lau, Aware president, in a letter to the press:

    'Why have some people cast aspersions on our good intentions? Why are they so angry with us? We've only just begun.

    'We seek to improve the quality of life in Singapore. We are pro-women, pro-family and pro-Singapore.

    'What is so objectionable about that? Does the old guard harbour an alternative agenda? If so, they should disclose their motives and objectives fully and honestly.'

    Aware veteran members Ms Margaret Thomas, Ms Corrina Lim, Ms Braema Mathi, Ms Dana Lam, and Ms Tan Joo Hymn, representing the signatories of the requisition:

    'Our initial questions remain - what do you want to do in Aware that is fundamentally different from what was already being done?

    Click to see larger image

    'If you think the work Aware has done all these years is so good and you want to 'honour' and 'build' on it, why the need to muscle your way into the exco? Such a tactic suggests there may be a hidden agenda that may be contrary to the stance and ethos of Aware.'

    Secular or...

    Ms Lau:

    'Aware is a secular organisation. Its members come from different races, walks of life and hold different belief systems. Our commitment to advancing the cause of women unites us. As a democratic society, we cherish viewpoint diversity.'

    Aware's veteran members

    'We were further alarmed by media reports that the new Aware president led the marketing team in DBS' credit card campaign last year which supported the evangelical Christian organisation Focus on the Family.

    'Aware is a secular organisation that embraces diversity of race, age, religion, culture and sexuality. It must remain so.'


    WHO'S WHO IN NEW AWARE LEADERSHIP

    EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE MEMBER

    Catherine Tan Ling Ghim (above, extreme left): Financial planner. Member of Million Dollar Round Table.

    EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE MEMBER

    Peggy Leong Pek Kay (above, second from left): Lecturer at Ngee Ann Polytechnic's School of Humanities. Has 16years of teaching experience.

    HONORARY SECRETARY

    Jenica Chua Chor Ping (above, in red top): In her 30s. Management consultant with top business technology company.

    HONORARY TREASURER

    Maureen Ong Lee Keang (above, in patterned top): Last appointment was executive vice-president at SembCorp Group.

    VICE-PRESIDENT

    Charlotte Wong Hock Soon (above, wearing glasses): Consultant with ExxonMobil, where she worked for 21 years. Former sociology and anthropology lecturer at National University of Singapore.

    EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE MEMBER

    Lois Ng (above): 44

    Social entrepreneur who runs business that hires disabled people to produce gifts for tourists and corporate markets.

    Former journalist, with The New Paper 1990-1995.

    ASSISTANT HONORARY TREASURER

    Chew I-Jin (above, wearing glasses): Aware member since May 1995. Previously served on Exco in 1995-1996, and as honorary treasurer in 2008-2009.

    EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE MEMBER

    Irene Yee Khor Quin (above, in jacket): Over 10 years of professional experience in financial services.

    ASSISTANT HONORARY SECRETARY

    Sally Ang Koon Hian (above, in ruffled top): Runs own law firm, Sally Ang Ebenezer and Company. Has more than 30years of legal experience.

    PRESIDENT

    Josie Lau Meng-Lee (above, extreme right): 48, vice-president and head of marketing, cards and unsecured Loans, DBS. Mother of two daughters, aged 17 and 15. Married to Dr Alan Chin Yew Liang, who owns several clinics under the Lifeline Medical Group. 'Ms Lau is concerned about work-life balance and the role of mothers as a stabilising factor in a family,' an Aware statement said.

    EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE MEMBER

    Caris Lim Chai Leng (not pictured): Freelance social worker, counsellor and trainer. Member of Aware since 2000. Exco member in 2008-2009.

    http://forums.delphiforums.com/sunkopitiam/messages?msg=27320.1

    Saturday, April 18, 2009

    Why Claire Nazar quit

    Why she quit

    Weekend • April 18, 2009

    Ms Claire Nazar told Today, it became clear after the exco’s first meeting that they “were not going to follow my direction”. “The exco and I didn’t see eye to eye. It was unfortunate. It was pointless for me to carry on as I didn’t want to waste time in politicking.”

    For instance, she wanted the current sub-committee chairs to retain their posts; the others felt differently. And, when she wanted to release a statement saying she would focus on working mothers during her one-year term, the exco “wanted to deliberate another week”.

    Ms Nazar said she wished Ms Josie Lau all the best and remains an Aware member.

    http://forums.delphiforums.com/sunkopitiam/messages?msg=27340.6